• Home
  • News & Current Affairs
  • Brexit
  • Politics
  • Podcasts
    • The Eamonn Mallie Podcast
    • Eamonn Mallie – Stream Of Consciousness
Facebook Twitter Instagram
Saturday, June 3
  • About Eamonn Mallie
  • Published Books
  • Our Authors
  • Get In Touch
Facebook Twitter
Eamonn Mallie
  • Home
  • News & Current Affairs
  • Brexit
  • Politics
  • Podcasts
    • The Eamonn Mallie Podcast
    • Eamonn Mallie – Stream Of Consciousness
Eamonn Mallie
You are at:Home»News & Current Affairs»LEGACY – MAKING A PATH TO PUBLIC CONSULTATION – By Brian Rowan 
News & Current Affairs

LEGACY – MAKING A PATH TO PUBLIC CONSULTATION – By Brian Rowan 

Brian RowanBy Brian RowanApril 4, 2017Updated:April 4, 2017No Comments3 Mins Read
Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email
Social share:

 

Inside the Stormont negotiations on Tuesday they were talking again about the legacy question.

Across two sessions, representatives of the five largest political parties discussed an issue that has been talked out and talked through across numerous consultations and negotiations.

In the afternoon British Secretary of State James Brokenshire and Irish Foreign Minister Charlie Flanagan joined the conversation.

Sir Jeffrey Donaldson was in the room, Emma Little Pengelly, Gerry Kelly, Sean Murray, Colin McGrath of the SDLP, who in one meeting was joined by John Dallat and in the other by Dolores Kelly. David Ford and Stephen Farry were the Alliance representatives, while former soldiers Tom Elliott and Doug Beattie are the Ulster Unionist negotiators in these legacy talks.

We know from a talks paper that the two governments are steering this issue towards public consultation; Brokenshire more enthusiastically than Flanagan was the observation of the one of the negotiators in the room.

Brokenshire is said to have been keen to stress that consultation does not equal a fait accompli.

“What is there to consult about?” a source from outside the talks asked when this path of the governments became clear.

How much longer can these parties and these governments talk about something that they have been talking about since the Eames/Bradley process began a decade ago?

Is public consultation an admission of defeat dressed up as something else?

Will this approach settle the arguments over national security – described by some as a smothering blanket to bury information and truth?

The IRA and loyalist organisations will of course have similar smothering blankets, although there is less talk about this.

At Stormont, on Wednesday morning, the same five parties and the two governments will return to their legacy discussion.

At some point – the Victims Commissioner Judith Thompson – is to be asked to advise “on how best a public phase can be conducted”?

The talk from inside the talks is that the parties want to be clearer about the detail of any consultation before that next step is taken.

Will the issue of funding for legacy inquests be settled before then?

A consultation may lift this issue out of the political negotiations for now, but will it really make things better or clearer?

What might the response be from the loyalist community and organisations, who have no place at the talks table?

What if a consultation produces a significant argument for the drawing of some line?

Has all of this been thought through, or is it a means of kicking an unanswerable and impossible question yet further down the road?

Will the talking over the next number of days answer any of these questions?

Are we any closer to an agreed process on the past?

One thing there seems to be agreement on is that the five years suggested for any such process will not be long enough.

 


Social share:
Previous ArticleTEN DAYS TO SAVE STORMONT – EXCLUSIVE DETAILS – By Brian Rowan 
Next Article A solution to the Gordian knot of dealing with the past – by Patrick Corrigan
Brian Rowan
Brian Rowan
  • Twitter

Brian Rowan is a journalist/author. A former BBC correspondent in Belfast, four times he has been a category winner in the Northern Ireland Press and Broadcast Awards. He is the author of several books on the peace process. His latest book (published by Merrion Press) POLITICAL PURGATORY – the battle to save Stormont and the play for a New Ireland is now available at www.merrionpress.ie

Related Posts

How the killings of two men 25 years ago helped to break the deadlock in the Peace Talks resulting in the Good Friday Agreement – by Mark Durkan

March 4, 2023

Life in politics by Monica McWilliams seen through the lens of former Northern Ireland Assembly speaker Dr. John Alderdice

February 15, 2022

‘The Troubles were just there, part of our normal…’  – By Brian Rowan 

January 26, 2022

Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

Our Picks

How the killings of two men 25 years ago helped to break the deadlock in the Peace Talks resulting in the Good Friday Agreement – by Mark Durkan

March 4, 2023

Life in politics by Monica McWilliams seen through the lens of former Northern Ireland Assembly speaker Dr. John Alderdice

February 15, 2022

‘The Troubles were just there, part of our normal…’  – By Brian Rowan 

January 26, 2022

The Health System Needs Surgery – by Mark Sidebottom

November 19, 2021
Follow me on Twitter
Tweets by @EamonnMallie
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
About
About

Northern Ireland's home for Independent thought. News & Current Affairs from Northern Ireland. Opinions, The Arts, Sports & more.

We're social, connect with us:

Facebook Twitter
Popular Posts

How the killings of two men 25 years ago helped to break the deadlock in the Peace Talks resulting in the Good Friday Agreement – by Mark Durkan

March 4, 2023

Life in politics by Monica McWilliams seen through the lens of former Northern Ireland Assembly speaker Dr. John Alderdice

February 15, 2022

‘The Troubles were just there, part of our normal…’  – By Brian Rowan 

January 26, 2022
Recent Comments
  • truck headlights on The Unacceptable Faces of the DUP and Sinn Féin – By Eamonn Mallie
  • Annemarie McQuade on West Belfast man SIMPLY wants UVF to publicly acknowledge father’s killing – By Paul Crawford
  • güzellik merkezleri on The Unacceptable Faces of the DUP and Sinn Féin – By Eamonn Mallie
Copyright ©Eamonn Mallie. Designed by Web Design Belfast.
  • Copyright

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.