• Home
  • News & Current Affairs
  • Brexit
  • Politics
  • Podcasts
    • The Eamonn Mallie Podcast
    • Eamonn Mallie – Stream Of Consciousness
Facebook Twitter Instagram
Monday, June 5
  • About Eamonn Mallie
  • Published Books
  • Our Authors
  • Get In Touch
Facebook Twitter
Eamonn Mallie
  • Home
  • News & Current Affairs
  • Brexit
  • Politics
  • Podcasts
    • The Eamonn Mallie Podcast
    • Eamonn Mallie – Stream Of Consciousness
Eamonn Mallie
You are at:Home»News & Current Affairs»Opinion»‘A SEAT BUT NOT THE CHAIR – Brokenshire and the next legacy battle’ – By Brian Rowan
Opinion

‘A SEAT BUT NOT THE CHAIR – Brokenshire and the next legacy battle’ – By Brian Rowan

Brian RowanBy Brian RowanFebruary 13, 2017Updated:February 23, 20171 Comment3 Mins Read
Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email
Social share:


The post-election negotiations have yet another issue on the agenda – the position of chair for the next talks on the past.

Secretary of State James Brokenshire is now part of that tug-of-war – the withholding of funding for legacy inquests and his commentary on conflict investigations casting him in the role of player rather than facilitator.

“London is disqualified because of Brokenshire’s behaviour,” Alex Attwood of the SDLP told this website – a position he has relayed to the Irish Government.

Several days ago, Sinn Fein’s leader in the North Michelle O’Neill told BBC The View that she did not consider the Secretary of State “an honest broker” and agreed someone external would be “preferable” as chair.

Unionists disagree.

“We tried an international Chair before in the form of Richard Haass and it just didn’t work,” DUP MP Sir Jeffrey Donaldson told eamonnmallie.com.

“They weren’t knowledgeable enough on the issues,” Donaldson continued – this a barrier he believed in trying to craft language and proposals that would achieve consensus.

“In contrast, the previous Secretary of State [Theresa Villiers] succeeded where Haass failed in securing the Stormont House Agreement and it is this accord that now needs to be taken forward,” Donaldson said.

“Therefore, the current Secretary of State is the right person to chair further talks. Any other option could result in a chair without the corporate knowledge needed to ensure competency and [could]lead to a rapid unravelling of the Stormont House proposals.”

Those proposals are for a Historical Investigations Unit, an Independent Commission on Information Retrieval, an Implementation and Reconciliation Group and Oral History Archive.

That agreement has since become a disagreement in arguments over British National Security and the withholding of information.

Loyalists have not been involved in negotiations and it is far from clear how the loyalist groups and the IRA would cooperate with any legacy process.

The SDLP believes the chair, or chairs, of future legacy talks should be tasked with determining what the quality and character of engagement with that process will be.

On the question of who should chair those talks, party leader Colum Eastwood told this website:

“There is no way that he [Brokenshire] can be in a position to chair the legacy element of any talks given his very partisan and public views on these issues.

We need an independent chair so that we can finally create the structures that will allow victims and survivors to find a path to truth and justice.”

Sinn Fein met Brokenshire on Monday and in a statement this evening reiterated its position.

But Ulster Unionist MP Tom Elliott said Brokenshire should chair the talks:

“I don’t see why he wouldn’t. He’s the Secretary of State,” Elliott commented.


He said the Stormont House proposals were not an agreement – “more a framework”.

So, could Brokenshire achieve that agreement?

“He probably has as much chance as anybody else,” Elliott responded.

Legacy consultations and talks have stretched across the past decade. Now, more discussions will follow the March 2 election – the latest negotiations trying to find an answer to a question that thus far has proved impossible.
And, before the talking, there is that new issue to be settled – the position of chair; Brokenshire or someone else?


Social share:
ae17 Tom Elliott UUP
Previous Article‘The SDLP is asking voters to vote for change and we are also asking them to transfer for change’ – Colum Eastwood
Next Article ‘Brexit means there can be no parity between Britishness and Irishness in the United Kingdom’s lawful territory’ – By Jamie Bryson
Brian Rowan
Brian Rowan
  • Twitter

Brian Rowan is a journalist/author. A former BBC correspondent in Belfast, four times he has been a category winner in the Northern Ireland Press and Broadcast Awards. He is the author of several books on the peace process. His latest book (published by Merrion Press) POLITICAL PURGATORY – the battle to save Stormont and the play for a New Ireland is now available at www.merrionpress.ie

Related Posts

POLITICAL PURGATORY or POLITICAL HELL? – By Brian Rowan 

April 18, 2021

The dilemma facing Unionism on all fronts – By Dave Maley

February 5, 2021

A Referendum on Irish Unity – An Economic Imperative – By Gerry Carlile

October 20, 2020

1 Comment

  1. Peter Gill on February 13, 2017 8:36 pm

    Mr.Obama

    Reply

Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

Our Picks

How the killings of two men 25 years ago helped to break the deadlock in the Peace Talks resulting in the Good Friday Agreement – by Mark Durkan

March 4, 2023

Life in politics by Monica McWilliams seen through the lens of former Northern Ireland Assembly speaker Dr. John Alderdice

February 15, 2022

‘The Troubles were just there, part of our normal…’  – By Brian Rowan 

January 26, 2022

The Health System Needs Surgery – by Mark Sidebottom

November 19, 2021
Follow me on Twitter
Tweets by @EamonnMallie
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
About
About

Northern Ireland's home for Independent thought. News & Current Affairs from Northern Ireland. Opinions, The Arts, Sports & more.

We're social, connect with us:

Facebook Twitter
Popular Posts

How the killings of two men 25 years ago helped to break the deadlock in the Peace Talks resulting in the Good Friday Agreement – by Mark Durkan

March 4, 2023

Life in politics by Monica McWilliams seen through the lens of former Northern Ireland Assembly speaker Dr. John Alderdice

February 15, 2022

‘The Troubles were just there, part of our normal…’  – By Brian Rowan 

January 26, 2022
Recent Comments
  • truck headlights on The Unacceptable Faces of the DUP and Sinn Féin – By Eamonn Mallie
  • Annemarie McQuade on West Belfast man SIMPLY wants UVF to publicly acknowledge father’s killing – By Paul Crawford
  • güzellik merkezleri on The Unacceptable Faces of the DUP and Sinn Féin – By Eamonn Mallie
Copyright ©Eamonn Mallie. Designed by Web Design Belfast.
  • Copyright

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.