Silence of the Shinnerbots – and Shame of the Media – by Jane de Courcey

Social share:



I had a dream the other night. Not a noble, impassioned dream in the style of Martin Luther King, but a nasty, disconcerting little dream which started with an image of Gerry Kelly tying his shoelaces.

(An image of Gerry Kelly can never herald the start of a pleasant dream.)

SF’s North Belfast standard-bearer seemed to be tying his laces just a wee bit too tight for my liking and I wondered what – or who – he was thinking of. And then I saw the rest of the leaflet…

‘Make the Change, Make History’, it proclaimed, alongside a bar chart trumpeting figures from the 2011 Census. Protestant – 45.67%; Catholic 46.94%.

Dreams can, as we all know, be difficult to interpret but in this case the message seemed clear: ‘Us Taigs have outbred youse Prods, so youse uns are toast.’

As Gerry tied those laces (and him pictured alongside a delightful tree-lined stream), I awoke in a cold sweat. Was Sinn Féin really playing the ultra-sectarian card? Had someone at party HQ really thought this was a good idea?

What about the ‘equality agenda’? What about ‘A Shared Future’? What about the ‘outreach to Protestants’ spearheaded by the fragrant Martina Anderson a few years ago?

Or was this a case of Gerry Adams’ ‘Trojan Horse’ spreading its Republican legs and racing to the electoral finishing líne in a two-horse race?

Twitter was ablaze with justifiable outrage at this revolting and squalid little piece of toilet-paper politics, as Tweeters of all backgrounds roundly condemned a clear attempt to turn the election into a religious headcount.

For once, the Shinnerbots were silent. Normally vigorous in their defence of the Republican ideal, SF’s keyboard warriors kept their typing fingers firmly in their pockets.

All attempts to engage with the usual suspects proved futile.

There was no denial and there was no attempt to defend. Just silence. The Silence of the Shinnerbots. Danny Morrison broke ground, responding to a thread with fast-increasing grumpiness and saying: ‘Journalists, media pundits, commentators, all use these statistics as a rough rule of thumb.’

(Another tweet from a leading SF politician in North Belfast seems to have disappeared from my timeline.)

Yet there was an even more disturbing silence. The silence of the media. One might have expected Stephen Nolan to be, as he irritatingly puts it, ‘all over the story’. Not a mention. Same with William Crawley and Talkback. It didn’t even merit a line in BBC news bulletins throughout the day.

SF weren’t invited to defend the leaflet, or even to claim it was a cruel hoax perpetrated by them devious Prods. Ignored totally. Yet had such a tawdry flyer issued from the PUL community, Nolan and Co would have been in full attack mode.

I think the colloquial expression is ‘creaming themselves’.

And the same goes for all of the media, both print and electronic. Zero coverage.

What SF tell their electorate on the doorsteps and say on the radio or telly might be two diferent things, but surely they have to be held to account in some way.

The mainstream media went ballistic over the Belfast Telegraph piece on women in politics (rightly so), but why was this story so completely and totally ignored? There couldn’t possibly be an agenda…could there?

Shame on them.

Perhaps I’d imagined the whole thing, even the full-page ad in a local paper which screamed ‘For the first time in 130 years there is a NATIONALIST MAJORITY in North Belfast. YOU CAN WIN’.

(In this, the odious little bar chart had changed to state: Unionist – 45.30%; Nationalist – 45.90%.)

Maybe it was all a dream. After all, Gerry Kelly is Sinn Féin’s Mr Fun and there he was, in my new reverie, canvassing a Star Wars Stormtrooper on a North Belfast doorstep.

I wonder if it was a Protestant Stormtrooper or a Catholic one…

Social share:

About Author


  1. Jane, if you are having dreams about Gerry Kelly, I would suggest you are in urgent need of psychiatric help, so the rest of your article has to be read with that in mind.
    The Sinn Fein leaflet may be sectarian, though it might be argued that its just drawing attention to statistics.
    But would it be any more sectarian than the DUP/UUP pact to freeze out nationalist/republican candidates?
    Or the fact that Jim Allister is not standing candidates in constituencies where his TUV might allow a nat/rep candidate to win?
    Or the fact that David Cameron (who claims not to be sectarian) has candidates standing in 16 constituencies, but not in FST or North Belfast, lest Tory intervention would allow Sinn Fein’s Michelle Gildernew or Gerry Kelly to become MPs?
    Is your condemnation of perceived sectarianism only one-sided or did you just forget to notice the other side of the coin?

  2. Desmond Mckinley on

    And a certain 40k leaflets circulated in EB, ganging up on Naomi Long. Because she had the audacity to stand against wee peter. Although not sectarian, it could be construed as exactly the same as Gerry Kelly’s wee leaflets. But which one was telling the truth?

  3. “it was a cruel hoax perpetrated by them devious Prods. Ignored totally. Yet had such a tawdry flyer issued from the PUL community, Nolan and Co would have been in full attack mode.”
    Woman who has no problem using the ugly term “Protestant, Unionist, Loyalist” gets upset when someone else suggests “Catholic, Nationalist” on a leaflet. Hypocrisy.

Leave A Reply