“Being British is about a tradition of shared ideas and values. Not bloodlines” – avows Brian John Spencer

Social share:

 

Thousands of peace demonstrators unite against racism  at Belfast city hall.

Thousands of peace demonstrators unite against racism at Belfast city hall.

 

You know you’ve entered the realm of the absurd when you get a telling-off from Jamie Bryson on electoral politics. Yet more absurd being tagged “monotonous” by a man who has spent the last year spilling monotony about the erosion of British-Protestant values and the appeasement of legitimate, elected politicians. Beyond absurd being labelled intolerant for criticising someone who preached intolerance when telling his congregation to mistrust Muslims. That last one bends the mind.

Jamie made a number of points against my original article, I want to address these in turn.

Firstly, my “scathing attack” on Peter Robinson was an exercise in free speech, not an attack on free speech. It was an exercise in accountability journalism directed towards the irresponsible and intolerant words and actions of the leader of 1.8 million people.

He, as First Minister of Northern Ireland, owes a blind statutory duty to treat all citizens equally, irrespective of religion or political allegiance. By making a shameless defence of Pastor McConnell’s racist comments, he has stigmatised and isolated a minority population and failed in his responsibility to the people, minority and majority populations, of Northern Ireland.

This episode isn’t about offending people. It isn’t a question of free speech (that’s simply a straw man created by members of the party who ironically oppose the liberalisation of speech laws.) This is about targeting a minority people and inciting a majority to fear that minority. And leave no doubt, Pastor McConnell made racist comments. He called Enoch Powell, a man whose apocalyptic vision of immigration incited race riots, a “prophet”.

Already The Irish News has reported on a victim of a vicious racist assault who said that Peter Robinson’s comments “lit the fire” that triggered the attack. Absurd words and ideas can mobilise people to commit horrific attacks.

On political correctness, I am on the record as repeatedly and robustly opposing this convention as the worst kind of censorship and the pernicious cause of self-censorship. I believe Islamic extremism exists. I believe that it needs to be fought and eradicated; but you do not fight extremism with the bombastic extremism exhibited by Pastor McConnell.

On being offended, I am also on the record as saying that this is an empty slogan that has become a vacuous and meaningless cultural tick.

To be clear, at no time did I say that anyone should be arrested or investigated or prosecuted for hate speech. You defeat bad speech with good speech and good argument, not prosecution and criminalisation. I oppose the New Labour hate and terror laws. I proscribe to the Glenn Greenwald school that says that “few ideas have done as much damage throughout history as empowering the government to criminalize opinions it dislikes.”

Secondly, Jamie speaks of “indigenous British people” and “British values”. This is ethno-fascist garbage.

British exceptionalism comes from its history of tolerance, pluralism and opposition to governments and people that preach religious and race purity. Being British is about a tradition of shared ideas and values. Not bloodlines.

There is no set British way of life. To say there is a proper indigenous British people makes a mockery and parody of Britishness. Stuart Hall, cultural theorist and founder of cultural studies, said:

“I think that the British have a future only if they can come to terms with the fact that Britishness is not one thing and has never been one thing there have been a million different ways of being British.”

Thirdly, it wouldn’t be Jamie Bryson if we didn’t hear from Churchill or Hitler. He’s a junky for Godwin’s law. A sure signal for bombast, myth, exaggeration and reckless overstatement.

The invocation and ventriloquising of Churchill and what Churchill would do is dangerous and this habit is giving him the sound of a sinister patriot who longs for the sweep of empire and the return of a greater Protestant Britain.

I take it as a great slander against my name to say I would appease the exterminationist Judophobia of the German National Socialists. I would not appease but fight that intolerance, just as I won’t appease but will fight the intolerance exhibited today in Northern Ireland.

I am an equal opportunities oppositionist and will shed light on madness and duplicity wherever I see it, that includes Pastor McConnell, Peter Robinson, violent minority of loyalists and the iliberalism of Islam as I sought to do here. I believe in civil intolerance and that requires us to promote tolerance and fight intolerance in conciliatory an constructive ways.

 


Social share:

About Author

Brian is a writer, artist and law graduate.

3 Comments

  1. Jamie is upper middle class and he knows it, thing is people if you ignore him. He will eventually go away, if you listen to him then he wins. And if you’re a protestant you get jailed cos of him, he also wins. Jamies parents are/have built a £2 million pound house round Groomsport, not bad for someone who claims to come from a working class background like the 163 people he claims to represent. Focus on getting our Government back and less on Bryson!

  2. Brian, you seem concerned at the absurdity of being criticised by our Jamie.

    Would you not worry more about what you had said or written if Jamie gave you his full support?

    Jamie does seem indeed to be a Winston Churchill fan – does he realise that his hero came to Northern Ireland promoting Home Rule for Ireland?

  3. Being British in Northern Ireland always meant being Protestant from the state’s foundation. That’s how the Protestants wanted it. It’s very noticeable now that unionism cannot deny the demographic changes anymore, that Northern Ireland’s Britishness is apparently open to everyone (potenian pro union Catholics) and not dependent on being Protestant and royalist.

    “Britishness” in reality is as meaningless a term as Scandinavian. Are the Scandinavians similar people? Yes. Do they all need share the same state and passports? NO.

Leave A Reply